← Back to Stephen Ta | Portfolio
The T-Shirt Index
Fabric comparisons, collar durability tests, fit opinions, and price-to-value verdicts.
Reviewer Sizing Baseline
5'8" • 155 lbs • Average build with broad shoulders.
All shirts are machine washed and tumble dry low.
Standard Sizing Reference:S/M (US Brands) • M/L (EU/APAC Brands)
Testing Focus: Most of my tests are 100% cotton shirts. I have tried blended shirts, but much prefer the quality, longevity, and natural softness of pure cotton. I did not include mainstream brands on this list, though I have worn plenty in the past such as Uniqlo, Abercrombie & Fitch, and Lululemon. Those are good for the price and easy to buy, but this journey is specifically about finding the best quality shirts crafted for the classic heritage menswear space.
Shirts Tested
18library items
Top Tier (S Tier)
4highest benchmark
Avg Price
$86USD retail per shirt
Shirts I Will Review Next
| Status | Brand & Model | Size | Weight | Price | What I'm Testing |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| In Transit | Wonder Looper ELS Recycled Cotton Slub T-Shirt | M | 280 GSM | $120 | Testing 280 GSM heavyweight drape, slub texture hand-feel & collar shape retention |
| In Transit | Wonder Looper Foxfibre® Tsuriami Loopwheel T-Shirt | M | 228 GSM (6.7 oz) | $135 | Authentic Wakayama loopwheel softness, natural un-dyed cotton & seamless tubular fit |
| On Deck | 3sixteen Heavyweight Classic Crew T-Shirt (2-Pack) | M | 260 GSM (9 oz) | $95 | Custom jersey torso shrink rate, collar elasticity, and value vs Whitesville |
| On Deck | Buck Mason Toughknit™ Tubular Tee (2-Pack) | M | 200 GSM | $88 | Testing their new seamless tubular construction compared to their classic cut-and-sew tees |
| On Deck | Buck Mason Field-Spec Cotton Heavy Tee | M | 310 GSM | $62 | Heavyweight 310 GSM structure, torso boxiness & durability under warm machine dries |
| On Deck | Buck Mason Slub Classic Curved Hem Tee | M | 145 GSM | $45 | Summer breathability, curved hem drape & collar bacon resistance on slub yarn |
| On Deck | Kaptain Sunshine Suvin Supima Tube Crewneck Tee | M (38) | 210 GSM | $125 | Rare Suvin/Supima yarn softness, high-twist crisp hand-feel & tubular boxy drape |
Wonder Looper
In TransitELS Recycled Cotton Slub T-Shirt
Size: M280 GSM$120
"Testing 280 GSM heavyweight drape, slub texture hand-feel & collar shape retention"
Wonder Looper
In TransitFoxfibre® Tsuriami Loopwheel T-Shirt
Size: M228 GSM (6.7 oz)$135
"Authentic Wakayama loopwheel softness, natural un-dyed cotton & seamless tubular fit"
3sixteen
On DeckHeavyweight Classic Crew T-Shirt (2-Pack)
Size: M260 GSM (9 oz)$95
"Custom jersey torso shrink rate, collar elasticity, and value vs Whitesville"
Buck Mason
On DeckToughknit™ Tubular Tee (2-Pack)
Size: M200 GSM$88
"Testing their new seamless tubular construction compared to their classic cut-and-sew tees"
Buck Mason
On DeckField-Spec Cotton Heavy Tee
Size: M310 GSM$62
"Heavyweight 310 GSM structure, torso boxiness & durability under warm machine dries"
Buck Mason
On DeckSlub Classic Curved Hem Tee
Size: M145 GSM$45
"Summer breathability, curved hem drape & collar bacon resistance on slub yarn"
Kaptain Sunshine
On DeckSuvin Supima Tube Crewneck Tee
Size: M (38)210 GSM$125
"Rare Suvin/Supima yarn softness, high-twist crisp hand-feel & tubular boxy drape"
Tier:
Showing 18 of 18 reviewed teesClick any row to reveal detailed collar construction, wash tests & notes
| Tier | Brand & Model | GSM | Fit & Sizing | Size | Price & Value | Collar Durability | Recommendation & Thoughts | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| S | 2-Pack Tubular Crewneck Japan | 215 GSM | Classic Size Up (Runs Small) | L/XL | $90.00 Exceptional Value | Binder Neck Rib Zero Baconing | “Based on fit and value, these are one of my all-time favorites. I own 6 of them in different colors. If you are in Japan, you can get a 2-pack for around $60 USD after conversion.” | |
| S | 2M15 Modern Fit Crewneck Portugal / Germany | 230 GSM | Relaxed Size Up (Runs Small) | L | $95.00 Good Value | 1x1 Ribbed Crew Sturdy Retention | “A slightly cheaper, modernised counterpart to the 215 with side seams. Like all Merz b. shirts it runs small, so size up. The fit is a bit looser, making it perfect for summer.” | |
| S | Our T-Shirt (2-Pack) USA (Los Angeles) | 200 GSM | Classic True to Size | M | $105.00 Fair / Premium | 1" Bound Rib Zero Baconing | “As close to a perfect classic fit as it gets. While it might not be the single softest shirt on day one, the fit and construction quality are top notch. The 2-pack offers solid value.” | |
| S | 215 Loopwheeled Crewneck Germany | 245 GSM | Classic Size Up (Runs Small) | L | $120.00 Fair / Premium | Bound Loopwheel Zero Baconing | “My favorite casual tee overall. Like all Merz b. shirts it runs small, so I sized up. The loopwheel construction feels incredible and the collar has not loosened at all over time.” | |
| A | Tubular Loopwheel Athletic Tee China | 220 GSM | Classic True to Size | M | $28.00 Exceptional Value | Ribbed Vintage Band Sturdy Retention | “A great all-season tee with a fitted chest and clean drape. Keep in mind it runs slightly short in torso length and will shrink about half an inch after several washes.” | |
| A | 9913 Loopwheel T-Shirt Japan | 295 GSM | Classic Size Up (Runs Small) | L | $105.00 Good Value | 3-Needle Binder Zero Baconing | “If you want a heavy, stiff standalone shirt with bulletproof construction, this is one of my top picks. Definite standalone piece that should not be used for layering.” | |
| A | Heavyweight Solid Crewneck Japan | 260 GSM | Classic Size Up (Runs Small) | L | $110.00 Fair / Premium | 3-Needle Binder Zero Baconing | “While I was not blown away initially, this shirt drapes exceptionally well in casual outfits. The heavy fabric gets noticeably softer with every wash while the collar stays bulletproof.” | |
| A | Rugby T-Shirt USA (Los Angeles) | 320 GSM | Boxy True to Size | M | $110.00 Good Value | 10 oz Heavy Rib Zero Baconing | “Lady White’s heaviest shirt. Built like a tank with a great boxy, relaxed fit. Do not wear this on hot summer days or you will literally need help peeling it off.” | |
| A | 214 Relaxed Fit Loopwheel Germany | 245 GSM | Relaxed Size Up (Runs Small) | L | $120.00 Fair / Premium | Bound Loopwheel Zero Baconing | “The relaxed cut counterpart to the famous 215. All Merz b. shirts run small so I sized up to an L. The extra room through the chest and arms makes it a great casual, easy-wearing staple.” | |
| B | 1009 Heavyweight T-Shirt Canada | 235 GSM | Classic True to Size | M | $38.00 Exceptional Value | 1x1 Heavy Tape Sturdy Retention | “A great classic fit that is solidly built and frequently discounted during seasonal sales. One of the few brands offering rich colors outside standard black, white, and grey.” | |
| B | The T-Shirt Portugal | 180 GSM | Classic True to Size | M | $55.00 Good Value | Refined 1x1 Rib Sturdy Retention | “A great standard classic fit from Sweden. The modular sizing (Short, Regular, Long) makes this an easy recommendation if you struggle to find the right torso length.” | |
| C | Midweight Jersey T-Shirt Vietnam / Canada | 235 GSM | Relaxed Size Down (Runs Large) | S | $65.00 Fair / Premium | Flatlock Set-in Rib Moderate | “This is the brand that first got me obsessed with basic tees years ago. Lean towards a relaxed casual fit that looks great with a baseball cap, but quality has slipped post-acquisition.” | |
| C | 2-Pack Tubular Crewneck Japan | 210 GSM | Boxy Size Up (Runs Small) | L | $95.00 Good Value | Reinforced Rib Sturdy Retention | “Decent shirts and a solid value for a 2-pack. They fit boxier than Whitesville, but overall I much prefer Whitesville in this category.” | |
| C | Classic Crew Neck T-Shirt England / Portugal | 160 GSM | Slim True to Size | S | $115.00 Overpriced | Bound Q82 Neck Moderate | “Very soft, slim-fitting British classic. If you can grab it on a heavy sale it is worth trying, but I would never recommend buying this at full retail ($115+).” | |
| D | AO Curve-Hem Tee China | 200 GSM | Slim True to Size | M | $58.00 Overpriced | Synthetic Stitched Prone to Baconing | “Synthetic polyester blend tee. While stretchy and soft, it lacks the structure and natural feel I look for. I now strictly use these for lounging or as bedtime shirts.” | |
| D | Circular Knit T-Shirt Canada | 205 GSM | Classic True to Size | S | $68.00 Overpriced | Circular Ribbed Moderate | “Runs with a shorter crop and had seam separation issues at the armpit. If you want a Canadian circular knit, House of Blanks is far superior.” | |
| D | Lot 4601 Slub Cotton Tee Japan | 175 GSM | Classic Size Up (Runs Small) | L | $80.00 Overpriced | 1960s Binder Rib Moderate | “A highly praised slub-textured shirt in the heritage community, but it did not work for me. The chest is tight in awkward spots and the cotton feels too stretchy.” | |
| D | Midweight T-Shirt Portugal | 220 GSM | Relaxed True to Size | M | $95.00 Overpriced | Self-Fabric Rib Moderate | “A blended Lyocell and Pima cotton shirt. Very silky and comfortable for airport travel or lounging, but lacks the structure needed for a proper everyday outfit tee.” |